I think it's fitting that my first recipe post is key lime pie. I grew up in Florida and lived in the state for 13 years, so I'm very familiar with the food. And of all the places I've been on vacation, Key West stands out in my mind the most.
A refreshingly cool dessert, key lime pie is traditionally made with key limes, which are basically impossible to find in stores. Much smaller than regular limes, I hear that (should you be able to find them) it takes between 20 and 25 limes to get the juice needed for this recipe.
I based my recipe off the one at Joe's Stone Crab, actually located in Miami. (The restaurant is a favorite of Bobby Flay, who claims the place's stone crabs are one of his all-time favorite dishes.) I've never eaten at the place, but I have had the key lime pie at Sloppy Joe's on Duval Street, possibly the most famous restaurant on what is definitely the most famous street on the key. Served way colder than what you'll find labeled key lime pie in your grocery store, the following dish is sweet, tart and most importantly refreshing.
The ingredients:
For this dish, you will need: 1 cup of lime juice (6-8 limes)
zest of half a lime
2 cans of evaporated milk, unsweetened (I used half fat free to make the dish a touch healthier)
5 egg yolks
5 tbsp. butter
10 graham crackers
1/4 cup sugar for the crust
1/2 cup sugar for the filling
whipped cream (optional)
The supplies you will need include:
knife
microplane zester
fork
whisk
plastic bag
rolling pin
two bowls for mixing
12-inch pie tin
sheet of wax or parchment paper
cooling rack
Preheat the oven to 375 degrees.
I'd recommend starting the dish by zesting 1/2 a lime and then juicing the limes, since this can be fairly time consuming if you don't have a juicer. Rub the rind of the lime against the microplane until you get 1/2 of the outside of one of the limes into one of your bowls. You might have to use a finger to get it off the zester, since limes are so moist.
The best way to get the most juice out of a lime is to nuke it in the microwave for 30 seconds and then massage the fruit against the counter to get the juices flowing. You can also ensure you're picking a juicy lime at the grocery store by taking the limes that seem heaviest for their size.
Once this is done, cut the limes in half and squeeze over a measuring cup. Limes are so small, you can actually get almost all the juice out by turning the fruit halves inside out and squeezing out even more juice. And actually, wouldn't these make really cute little shot glasses for Cinco de Mayo? They sort of look like little sombreros.
Using this method, it took me only 6 limes to get 1 cup of juice. Set aside your juice and your bowl of zest for later.
Now take your 10 graham crackers and place them in your sealable plastic bag. Then take your rolling pin and basically beat the hell out of your bag of crackers! By the end of the process, your baggy should be full of delicious graham cracker crumbs.
As you are beating up your graham crackers, you can place your clean bowl (without any zest in it) in the microwave and melt the butter completely. Then pour the cracker crumbs into the butter bowl and mix with your fork until all the crumbs are slightly moist. Then add 1/4 a cup of sugar to the mixture and stir until uniformly distributed.
Pour your mixture into a greased 12-inch pie tin. I found the easiest way to press the crumbs into a crust shape is to place wax or parchment paper over the pile and press with your hands into the tin until the crumbs are creeping all the way up the sides of the dish. (Make sure to press on a flat surface or your pie crust could go flying!)
Put the crust into the oven for 8 minutes. The graham cracker crust should slightly change color during that time.
Meanwhile, take your bowl of zest and put in just the yolks of five eggs. (You can separate out the whites into another dish if you wish to use them immediately for another dish or you can let the whites go down the drain.) Beat the yolks for a bit with the whisk until they look a little aerated and bubbly. Then pour in the two cans of milk, 1/2 cup of sugar and cup of lime juice, whisking as you go.
Once the crust is finished cooking, pour in the filling, making sure not to overfill the dish. (This will make it EXTREMELY hard to maneuver the uncooked pie around.) If you want to avoid having a potentially huge mess on your hands, I recommend placing a cookie tin on the bottom rack of the oven and the pie tin (using your bare hands is easiest at this stage, I promise) on the top rack above it. This way, if it drips or if you spill at all, you don't have a disgusting oven. Cook the dish for another 10 minutes.
Now this is the hardest part of the entire dish: Ever so carefully, take the pie (which should still be fairly watery) out of the oven (oven mitts this time, since it's hot) and place it on a cooling rack. If you don't spill, pat yourself on the back, because I sure did! If you do, a little napkin to clean the tin (and the counter) makes the pie look the same once it's done.
Let the pie cool until it is room temperature. Then--get this--put it in the freezer! I was majorly skeptical of this step. The closest thing in consistency to this pie that I've made before is my mother's coconut custard pie (delicious), and that condensed milk dish requires way more cooking and absolutely no freezing. But think of your key lime pie as a cold treat on a hot day and stick it in the freezer! It takes about two hours to solidify. Take it out to thaw just a bit, for about 15-20 minutes, before serving.
The result: a delicious summer pie!
To plate it, I placed some whipped cream I had in the fridge on top and placed a slice from one of my left over limes and some zest on top.
In my next blog, read about my dinner adventure at The Irish Inn at Glenn Echo, Maryland.